In movies, there has always been an
enormous passion for period pieces. Pride and Prejudice.
Elizabeth. The Count of Monte Cristo. Gone With the
Wind. The Great Gatsby. Master and Commander: The Far
Side of the World. What all of these films have in common is a
romantic recreation of the past and what it was like to live in them.
Yes, most of these movies don't shy away from some points where we
see how nasty it could be to be around in these periods but, without
exception, we are asked to follow characters who are most able to
enjoy their surroundings and the benefits of their time. In
Elizabeth, we witness the travails of a princess who will
become queen. In Master and Commander, we follow the
friendship between a distinguished ship's captain and a skilled
doctor. In Pride and Prejudice, we watch an upper class girl
try to avoid arranged marriage in order to marry a man that she can
respect and love. First world problems much?
The point is that we have a fascination
with the past, one that is particularly focused the people with the
most freedom in their respective eras. Are there exceptions?
Absolutely. But, as a whole, we love reading stories of those who
have the immediate power to change their surroundings. We are
fascinated with times foreign yet familiar to our own, awestruck that
these periods once existed. This isn't fiction; it's real. And, while
we may focus on the stories of characters and events that are
fictional within these eras, it does not take away from the truth
that these dramas could have happened, and that the settings were
once vivid reality.
.
The Meteoric Rise of Napoleon
Bonaparte
Though I'm here reviewing a book and
not a movie, that introduction is perfect for describing the tone and
power of The War of Wars: The Great European Conflict 1793-1815.
This book is a history, a grand drama of a twelve year war, a massive
tome capable of knocking out any nearby housecat. It's about an era
that, for some reason, we never really see in movies. Whenever I've
shown this book to people asking about what I'm reading, the result
is immediate disinterest and surprise that anyone would read such a
gargantuan book about a long past conflict. And yet, despite all of
these negative factors, I'm here to tell you one thing:
This book fucking rocks.
The War of Wars imbues its time
period with vigorous life. Have you ever wondered how it feels to be
a frigate captain at sea? This book is filled with the grandeur of a
life in the navy, storming the crests of high waves in pursuit of the
enemy. Have you ever wondered what it's like to be a diplomat in
Paris? There's so much political intrigue and shenanigans in this
book that it is beyond compare. At every stage, we are given a
retelling of events from the French Revolution to Napoleon's invasion
of Egypt, from the cat-and-mouse naval chases of the Caribbean to the
epic battle of Waterloo; all fully factual, all possessed with a
page-turning narrative worthy of an award-winning novel. After
reading this book, I was frankly astonished that I've never seen a
movie about the Napoleonic Wars before. How have filmmakers missed
this? This era is filled with such drama, heroism, and conflict that
it's preposterous that it has not yet been immortalized in modern
film.
Dynamic Personalities
But if there's one thing that makes
this book great, it is the way the author brings the personalities of
the various figures into life. As hinted in my introduction, this
book focuses primarily on the statesmen, commanders, and leaders of
the period. Yet, despite a vast cast of characters stretched across
dozens of years, I never got lost. Just about every man and woman is
memorable. What's more, we are given a balanced view of them. It is
very easy for historians to get caught up in the near-mythic
brilliance of Napoleon, but Robert Harvey manages to hit both his
highs and his lows. We are able to appreciate Napoleon's genius
intensity, his quest for recognition, and determination to succeed.
Yet we are similarly able to witness his lack of self-control and
uncontrollable megalomania. Through this we get a multifaceted
perspective of Napoleon and many, many other 'great people' besides.
Even with those that the author obviously admires (such as Pitt the
Younger and Thomas Cochrane), we are shown their failings, petulance,
insecurities, and more. This serves to create an incredibly deep and
interesting cast of characters, unforgettable figures set amidst the
dramatic backdrop of Europe's first truly global war.
Critique
The first thing one should know going
into this, though, is that it is a general history meant to be
enjoyed by those who aren't fussy professors. Essentially, it is (in
my opinion) a well-balanced story of the Napoleonic War brought to
life but, if you're seeking more specifics about this or that
conflict, then it's best to look for a more focused book. You'll get
a superb overview of every single stage of the war here, but you
might come away wanting more. Perhaps the best way to put it is that
this is a great introduction to the Napoleonic War for anyone who
hasn't read of it before, a Napoleonic War 101 course, if you will.
For me, that was perfect. But for anyone looking for a deep
exploration of this or that battle or conflict, it might be best to
look elsewhere.
Aside from that, I'd point out that
some of the land battles and naval engagements were kind of hard to
follow. But, really, this is totally my own fault. There are a great
deal of detailed maps at the beginning of the book and, sloth that I
am, I found myself far too lazy to flip back to the front in order to
visualize what I was reading on the page. Regardless, I never felt
completely lost.
My last critique is that, like I
pointed out at the beginning, this history falls into the period
piece trap of focusing largely on the 'big' 'important' upper class
figures of the time. Unlike, say, the histories of Max Hastings, we
only occasionally get the perspective of the average citizen or
soldier of the time. This may damage its credibility as a truly
effective history. But I can honestly say that I just didn't care. I
was having too much fun. And at no time in this book did I feel like
I was wasting my time or getting too incomplete of a picture.
Conclusion
Thus it is that, in order to shower
praise upon a history with an exciting and sweeping narrative that is
perhaps a tad light on substance, I've created a review that only
sings lustrous praises and calls attention to dazzling adventures. I
didn't call much attention to the specific figures, I didn't really
talk about the incredible events, I didn't assess the immensely
interesting effect the Napoleonic War had on the world, ramifications
that we still feel to this very day. Perhaps I'll have to write a
follow-up to do that.
But for now just be assured that, if
you've ever had any passing interest in learning about this era of
history, this is the book to start your journey with. I can't
emphasize enough how excited this book makes me about teaching
history and calling attention to the spectacular events that have
happened in the past. And that's worth sharing.
No comments:
Post a Comment