I want to say that I loved The Dark
Knight Rises. It was a dense, complex movie with a lot going on.
This was both what made it great and what gave it flaws that perhaps
made it not quite as incredible as The Dark Knight which came
before. This is going to be rife with SPOILERS, so beware of this
going in.
.
Gotham's Reckoning
First off, I'm going to talk about what
made the movie awesome, and then nitpick it from another angle. I
loved Bane. I think they did an excellent job of turning him into a
fearsome villain with presence, a force that moves through Gotham
like a knife through butter. It is remarkable what Tom Hardy was able
to do with only body movements and the use of his eyes. And, what's
more, Bane is Batman's superior in almost every way, and it shows.
There isn't a fight in the film where Bane doesn't kick Batman's ass,
thoroughly. The only way he is overcome is through the cheap
trick of punching his mask, which felt about as rewarding as beating
Darth Vader by bitch-slapping his respirator.
It is worth noting that Christopher
Nolan improved on the Bane of the comics by, on top of making Bane
deadly, turning him into a sympathetic character. It is truly
touching that Bane, a prisoner, essentially sacrificed his humanity
to save the life of one little girl. Doing so turns him into what is
clearly a monster, unable to connect with people and discarding them
like sacks of worthless flesh. It is only with Talia that he is able
to become a protector and show a scintilla of compassion. I wish they
had spent more time on this dynamic, but given the twist of Talia's
appearance, it could not be.
.
Al-Ghul Resurgent
One thing important to note about this
movie is how important the events of Batman Begins are to the
plot. Indirectly, Liam Neeson's Ra's Al-Ghul drives the entire story;
Bane is trained by the League of Shadows and his plan mirrors their
twisted philosophy of purging civilizations in order to purify them
from corruption. Bane's excommunication from the League tells us two
things: it requires us to take him seriously since this is akin to
someone being kicked out of the Soviet Spetsnaz (an infamously
dangerous special forces) for being too violent; it also illustrates
that Bane is a dark shadow of what Batman could have become. It is
also worth noting that Talia's parasitical entrance into Gotham's
society would not have happened without Batman allowing Ra's to die
at the end of the first movie. Revenge drives the movie, with Ra's
Al-Ghul a specter above it all.
The Dark Knight Rises also
returns us to the Asian and Middle Eastern influences of Batman
Begins. I thought that one of the most powerful moments of that
first movie arose from Bruce Wayne's time abroad in the Tibetan
mountains, training with the League of Shadows. Similarly, Wayne's
time in captivity in this movie, as well as the backstory surrounding
where he is imprisoned, includes many of the more poignant scenes in
the film. It's interesting that the most intriguing moments for me in
this trilogy were the moments where we aren't in Gotham and when we
aren't dealing with Batman; instead, it is those moments where we
confront the psyche of the man behind the mask. We get a great deal
of that in The Dark Knight Rises, possibly more than any of
the movies that came before.
.
The Breaking of the Bat
Speaking of which, let's talk about
Batman. Christopher Nolan does three things that are shocking for a
comic book movie like this. First, he cripples Batman's spirit; the first half of the
movie is a trail of Batman seeking a purpose in a world that hates
him, and then being destroyed for it against the immutable wall of
Bane. Second, he cripples Batman's body; Bane's thrashing of Batman
is so brutal that he must spend months retraining his
body and popping his freaking vertebrae back into place.
Lastly, he kills Batman. Who does that? The only apparent way
that he gets out of it is by some weird factor of Christian Bale
being immune to nuclear explosions or Alfred being so mentally
deranged by the events of the movie that he hallucinates Bruce
Wayne's appearance in Europe. However, this is another area where I wished
that they would spend more time allowing events to resonate with the
audience. Things moved so fast that it was hard to connect with Bruce
Wayne's anguish; we were too swept up in Gotham going to hell that it
was more difficult to mull over the more quiet moments of the prison
and Batman rising from his slump.
.
The French Revolution
One thing which I thought very daring
on the part of Christopher Nolan was making clear references to the
French Revolution. That same French Revolution that brought on the
guillotine, the execution of Marie Antoinette, the kangaroo courts,
and an atmosphere where you could be killed for any reason; a
barely controlled anarchy. I have long regarded the French Revolution
as the most terrifying event I've ever read about in history. Imagine
going for a walk and being branded a traitor, brutally raped and
murdered, just because you wore a watch. This was a time
period where the lower class's hatred of the rich grew to such levels
that they would lynch, torture, and kill anyone who had even the
barest hint of privilege. If you spoke in a refined and polite
manner, you'd likely be pointed out and killed. People reported their
neighbors, old rivals, and anyone who pissed them off that day as
traitors to the new order. And, because the desire for a purge of
nobility was so powerful, it made absolutely no difference whether
the claims were true or false; they'd guillotine you anyways. People
accused one another just to focus the mob somewhere, anywhere,
else. It was worse than living under some warlord's or drug lord's
yoke; it was humans murdering one another for expressing rational
thought, a bloodbath that targeted civilization itself.
We see that same sort of spirit in the
revolution that Bane brings to Gotham. People are encouraged to
replace the existing order, to kill those in charge and to overturn
old idols. It is exemplified clearest at all in the monstrous court
created by Jonathan Crane, the Scarecrow of previous movies. He seats
himself atop a ruin of thrown papers, books, chairs, and tables, the
same devastation which Bane has brought to the order of Gotham. And,
from this perch, he listens to people try to explain why they aren't
guilty, but sentences them to death regardless, a mockery of the
justice system of old. The fear that overtakes replacement
Commissioner Foley is indicative of the same fear that overtook the
average person during the French Revolution; people hoped that by
remaining quiet and suppliant they might escape the carnage when, in
fact, what was needed was a gathering of the silent majority in
opposing it.
This was unexpectedly impressive food
for thought but, like with the meditation of Batman repairing his
sense of self, I felt that the French Revolution aspect of Bane's agenda came
by so fast that it wasn't allowed to fully resonate with the
audience. I'm willing to bet that the average movie goer completely
missed that this was a perfect cautionary warning of how the excesses
of groups like Occupy Wall Street could cause them to radically
deviate from their agenda. It also is a perfect fictional
illustration of the fact that, throughout history, we've seen
populist movements before and that they must be taken with a grain of
salt or risk spiraling dangerously out of control.
.
Conclusion
Altogether, I enjoyed The Dark
Knight Rises immensely, but I can't help but wish it had been a
longer movie or that it had tried to tackle a bit less. All the
points and characters that it brought up were incredibly interesting,
but I found myself wishing for some longer scenes, for things to slow
down just a little bit so some of what was happening could feel more
fleshed out and less frantic. This is, perhaps, a hilarious complaint
for a movie that's already three hours long. Perhaps this nitpick
should be rescinded in favor of the fact that this will lend itself
well to multiple viewings, which is always good for any movie.
But The Dark Knight is probably
the better movie, if only barely. I say this just because, upon
leaving The Dark Knight, I felt awed and thoughtful. By
contrast, upon leaving The Dark Knight Rises, I felt
overwhelmed and that I had a LOT to process. This isn't necessarily
bad, but it's worth noting that I didn't find myself reaching that
cathartic moment where the movie ends and everything feels tied
together. But, then again, it isn't like we had that moment with the
movie, Inception, either. It's a truly tough call.
If nothing else, I did want to comment
that I find the idea of Joseph Gordon-Levitt as a new Batman to be a
little bit ridiculous. It isn't that he doesn't have the acting
chops, it's more that he looks so young that I can't picture him in a
Batsuit without laughing. Also: Catwoman was well done by Anne
Hathaway but, like I predicted, I never felt like her presence in the
film was really necessary. Batman didn't have to be trapped
into a fight with Bane; he was going to fight him anyways. And
someone else could just as easily have saved him and helped him out
in the final confrontation. Her only salient point was giving Batman
a sort of curious kick in the pants at the beginning, prompting him
to stop being Howard Hughes and to put the Batsuit on again, if only
to recover a lost necklace.
Anyways, enough nitpicking. All in all,
it's a fantastic movie and I'll definitely be seeing it again at some
point. I'd be curious to hear other impressions in the comments
below, if anyone wants to contribute.